Navigating the future of generative AI: Promises, pitfalls, and concerns

You can alter the liveliness of the track components between low, medium, and high making the personalization of the song even more unique, depending on your dynamics and transitions from one section to another. Without creating an account, Soundraw enables users to use AI to compose music. You’ll be surprised by how effortless and enjoyable it is to produce music with the help of AI technology. It could reportedly see a tool developed allowing fans and creators to make tracks using recognisable vocals and melodies legitimately by paying the copyright owners, with artists able to opt out. Ministers had planned to relax copyright laws in a way that would allow AI to mine works for text and data, part of efforts to make the UK an artificial intelligence hub. But they reversed the proposals earlier this month after a backlash from the music industry.

This can then be used to create fake versions of songs – thereby undercutting labels and their talent. Musicians already have a frosty relationship with Silicon Valley, from the Y2K-era battles with Napster to more recent fights over streaming revenue with Spotify. Artificial intelligence seems poised to turbocharge those woes, with tools like Google’s MusicLM jumping in to replace jam sessions with AI prompts. Michael Nash, Universal Music’s executive vice president and chief digital officer, wrote earlier this year that the rise of AI could be a ‘calamity’ for the industry. The third largest music label Warner Music has also been in talks with Google for a product, according to sources close to the developments as per the Financial Times report. The ability to regulate your music, or to customize your product in various ways, is the most essential function offered by many AI songwriters—for example, tempo, bass, instruments, song length, song effects, etc.

Generative AI and Music Rights

AI programmes have become ingrained in the workflow of younger creatives, with those interviewed sharing how it has aided in increasing their productivity — whether it had been adopted for years or tested for only a couple of months. Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings. By submitting this form, you give your consent for MIDiA Research to process your personal information and contact you for the purpose of providing updates on marketing and company announcements. Experimentation has made its way into the mainstream as well, with hits like Travis Scott’s 2018 smash ‘SICKO MODE’. Another example is, of course, Bad Bunny, by all measures the biggest artist in the world. “I think everyone’s a little itchy [for innovation] right now”, Polachek noted.

It is helpful for individuals who need to compose a new song with a similar emotional impact to an existing song. Based on a few inputs from you, these free AI music generators will produce a brand-new tune. The Grammys, the music awards show, has suggested the industry will need to adapt to the tech, with any work generated using AI to be made eligible for entry. Earlier this year, Universal Music said people will have to choose «which side of history» they want to be on — on the side of artists and fans or «deep fakes, fraud and denying artists their due compensation». Prior to joining William Fry, Barry was the Director of Legal Affairs and Regulatory Compliance of IMRO.

Amper Music:

Of all the ways in which generative AI has hit the headlines in recent weeks, the growth of AI-generated music has created some of the greatest public astonishment. Inside the music industry, that astonishment is coupled with existential concerns for the future of the industry. Oliver Lock, Owen O’Rorke, and Ethan Ezra Howard at the law firm Farrer & Co have kindly provided Omdia with their thoughts on the legal considerations that are set to unfold in the next few years. Google Magenta, a research project exploring the role of machine learning as a tool in the creative process, has produced a collection of plugins for music generation built on its opensource tools and models. These can be played by anyone at home on a standard PC.The musical instrument NSynth Super, developed by Magenta with Google Creative Lab, takes a novel approach to music synthesis. Unlike a traditional synthesiser, which generates audio from components, like oscillators and wavetables, it uses deep neural nets to learn the characteristics of sounds, then create a completely new sound based on them.

We welcome that the Government listened to concerns on its original proposal regarding text and data mining, yet the threat of new legislation remains a possibility. Take as an example John Williams, one of our greatest and most popular living composers. Well, you could just take his music, feed it into an AI and use it to generate a film score. Just as we have seen with the advance of the internet, these technological developments bring huge opportunities, but also massive risks and challenges if we get it wrong; unless the right guardrails are in place for its development. UK Music Chief Executive Jamie Njoku-Goodwin sets out the complex challenges facing the music industry and the Government when it comes to the rapid advance of AI. It should not replace legal advice tailored to your specific circumstances.

Need Legal Advice? Book a Free Consultation

Yakov Livshits

Ecrett offers a level of control over AI-generated musical tracks that you won’t find in many other places. You can control the tempo and volume on the fly and change the length with immediate effects. Each musical instrument in the song has its own track, and you can control the instrument through the song, customizing beyond what the AI offered. Ecrett also lets you upload a video to the editor window so that you can see a preview of how the song will look if you make it the background score. “In the metaverse, there will be music collaboration spaces and music production event areas or venues. Generative AI is useful for creating ‘music stems’, and building a sort of catalogue of music elements that can then be used by people collaboratively to start making an entire song – something that was not happening in the past.

It would be quite something if we were to end up in a situation where the UK’s regulatory framework ends up less transparent and with weaker protections for copyright and property rights than the People’s Republic of China. If our standards are set at a low bar then this would undermine both the AI sector and creative genrative ai industries in the long-term. The AI industry can only benefit from high standards as it needs a successful creative sector to generate “new” products. Firstly, Government must put copyright and IP protection at the heart of its approach to AI, and commit categorically to there being no new copyright exceptions.

Melobytes is a technology that encourages original content creation and serves as a source of inspiration. To create a distinctive audio track, you can select the musical genre, the instruments, and the audio. Soundraw makes it very simple to create creative soundtracks for movies, podcasts, music videos, commercials, etc. With the help of Soundraw, you can make the music you want, deciding on its length, tone, style, and theme.

As Trapital’s Dan Runcie put it (in a piece about Drake, no less), “the streaming era has made it more lucrative to be consistently good than occasionally great”. With a sound that is so easy to pin down, though, it is no wonder that the first AI-generated song to truly rattle the industry is a fake Drake one. Maybe Rosalía was onto something — the future metric for artist success is unpredictability. At MassiveMusic, we prioritise addressing these key challenges as we focus on creating distinctive musical value for brands. As bespoke music creators, we’re looking into AI tools to expedite our production process while preserving human involvement for crafting high-quality music. Music companies can harness AI to streamline production, expanding their creative possibilities for more refined outputs.

In any case, even when the music created by AI does not infringe on other copyrighted materials and is new, there is a debate about the level of protection that can be granted to such works. In an interesting twist in the tale of Bob Sturm’s Irish folk music experiment, a mainstream UK news website published a story criticising the album as a fake made by ‘bot villains’. When Sturm was asked to provide an audio excerpt of machine-generated music to include with the piece, he instead sent a clip of a ‘real’ traditional Irish jig. Musicians working with AI often see it as a tool to enhance creation and a democratising force, but others worry the technology will become more dominant and ultimately displace musicians from their jobs.

The «author’s own intellectual creation» is generally regarded as requiring a higher standard of originality than the English case law standard. Many commentators consider that AI-created works that do not have a human author cannot meet this higher standard. However, there is uncertainty over how broadly the EU test applies in the UK, or whether it will continue to apply in the UK post-Brexit, and whether it contradicts the CDPA, which seems to provide protection for non-human authored works. Under English copyright law, works generated by AI, can theoretically be protected as works «generated by computer in circumstances such that there is no human author of the work» (s. 178, Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (CDPA)). In the UK, the proliferation of such tools comes at a time of increased scrutiny of the role of copyright and the remuneration of music creators and rightsholders, following the DCMS’s inquiry into the economics of music streaming. When a track by artist «Ghostwriter» was uploaded and then promptly removed from streaming services in April, it was the latest example of one of 2023’s most astonishing trends.

• In its current form, the AI model could help to create a crude recreation of the music in your head.
• The models and templates from the offered storage space are simpler to create and use.
• The concept of the Metaverse, while not riding the wave of popularity it was a year or two ago, is all the same, being transformed by generative AI.
• Listener perceptions are strongly impacted by knowledge of a song’s origins.

Mubert is an innovative AI generative music platform that brings together humans and algorithms to create personalized, royalty-free music for a wide range of purposes. Whether you’re a content creator, artist, developer, or listener, Mubert offers tailored solutions to meet your music needs. The song, Heart On My Sleeve, is believed to have been created using AI programming trained with artists’ music, something which UMG said ‘represents both a breach of our agreements and a violation of copyright law’. In April, an AI-generated song featuring the simulated voices of Drake and The Weeknd was pulled from streaming services by Universal Music Group for ‘infringing content created with generative AI’. As generative AI balloons, which have allowed anyone to create deep fake music, Google and Universal Music are reportedly working on modalities to license the voices and melodies of musicians used for AI-generated music. The development of artificial intelligence-based music makers is still in its infancy.